LLHL CHAMPIONS
| Year | Regular Season 1st Place | Playoff Champion |
| 1978 - 79 | Simpson | Drake |
| 1979 - 80 | Simpson | Simpson |
| 1980 - 81 | Lanigan | LeRoy |
| 1981 - 82 | Imperial | Lanigan |
| 1982 - 83 | Lanigan | Lanigan |
| 1983 - 84 | Imperial | Imperial |
| 1984 - 85 | Lanigan | Lanigan |
| 1985 - 86 | Watrous | Lanigan |
| 1986 - 87 | Lanigan | Lanigan |
| 1987 - 88 | Lanigan | Watrous |
| 1988 - 89 | Watrous | Watrous |
| 1989 - 90 | Watrous | Watrous |
| 1990 - 91 | Drake | Drake |
| 1991 - 92 | Watrous | Lanigan |
| 1992 - 93 | LeRoy | Watrous |
| 1993 - 94 | Watrous | Watrous |
| 1994 - 95 | Lanigan | Lanigan |
| 1995 - 96 | Watrous | Drake |
| 1996 - 97 | LeRoy | Watrous |
| 1997 - 98 | LeRoy | LeRoy |
| 1998 - 99 | Watrous | Watrous |
| 1999 - 00 | Lanigan | Lanigan |
| 2000 - 01 | Lanigan | Watrous |
| 2001 - 02 | LeRoy | LeRoy |
| 2002 - 03 | LeRoy | LeRoy |
| 2003 - 04 | LeRoy | LeRoy |
| 2004 - 05 | LeRoy | LeRoy |
| 2005 - 06 | LeRoy | LeRoy |
| 2006 - 07 | Drake | Watrous |
| 2007 - 08 | Drake | Watrous |
| 2008 - 09 | LeRoy | LeRoy |
| 2009 - 10 | Lanigan | Drake |
| 2010-11 | Drake | Drake |